Blue Owl Continues to Illustrate Private Credit's Struggles

Market Insights

Blue Owl Continues to Illustrate Private Credit's Struggles

A year of locked doors

In 2026, the semi-liquid private credit fund got its first real stress test, and the results are mixed. Nearly every major non-traded fund sold to wealthy individuals has received more withdrawal requests than it can pay. Most have responded by enforcing their 5% quarterly cap, meaning investors who want out get a fraction of their money back each quarter and wait in line for the rest.

The pressure is easing, but slowly and unevenly. Fitch Ratings found that average redemption requests at business development companies (BDCs) fell to 9.8% of assets in the third quarter, down from 10.8% in the second. That is still nearly double the 5% most funds will pay. Meanwhile, loan defaults in the asset class have kept climbing to record levels.

Blue Owl Capital has become the clearest example of what can go wrong. But almost every large manager in the space faces similar issues.

Blue Owl: the stress case

Blue Owl's stock is down about 67% from its January 2025 peak and recently traded near all-time lows. In March, co-founder Doug Ostrover told employees the firm would emerge from the storm stronger. Seven months later, the numbers have not cooperated.

Redemptions. Blue Owl built its $300 billion-plus platform largely by selling funds to wealthy individuals, raising about $50 billion from that channel between 2022 and 2025. That same investor base is now heading for the exit. Its flagship Blue Owl Credit Income Corp. (OCIC) received withdrawal requests equal to 21.9% of shares in the first quarter and 18.8% in the second. The WSJ reports the figure was about 17% in the third quarter, still above most competitors. Its tech-focused fund, OTIC, saw requests of 40.7% and then 38.1% in the first two quarters. Both funds paid out only 5% per quarter. In April, Moody's moved OCIC's outlook to negative, citing its higher-than-peer redemption requests.

A troubled smaller fund. Blue Owl Capital Corp. II, which the firm tried to restructure, stopped tender offers and began returning capital by selling loans. In February, a $600 million loan sale returned about 30% of investors' money, and by August, it had returned another 13%. As loans were sold or repaid, problem loans became a larger share of what remained. By August, about 10% of the remaining loans were in default and another 20% were underperforming. The fund recently posted its worst loss since the pandemic.

Fundraising. Blue Owl says institutions now account for 66% of its inflows. That share grew mainly because retail sales fell faster. In the second quarter, institutional fundraising fell 22% from a year earlier, while retail flows fell about 60%. The firm's main growth bet now is AI data center financing, which carries its own risk if sentiment toward AI turns.

Blue Owl points to its October shareholder update. It says OCIC has paid out $2.8 billion in six months, meeting about 60% of original tender requests, and that more than 90% of its 90,000 shareholders remain fully invested.

Everyone is in the same line, just at different spots

Blue Owl's figures are the worst among the big managers, but not by much. Six of the eight large funds below received third-quarter withdrawal requests of 10% or more, and all six paid out only 5%.

  • Blackstone. The $77 billion BCRED, the largest fund in the category, paid every request in full in the first quarter (7.9%), with Blackstone and its employees adding $400 million to make it work. In the second and third quarters, requests hit about 10% (roughly $4.3 to $4.5 billion each time), and the fund enforced the 5% cap. It has also cut its monthly distribution twice in nine months.

  • Apollo. Apollo Debt Solutions has capped withdrawals for three straight quarters. Requests went from 11.2% to 16.8% to 14.7%. Apollo says most of the demand came from investors outside the U.S.

  • Ares. The Ares Strategic Income Fund went from 11.6% to 14.4% to 13.1%. Ares says new requests were only about 3% of net assets in the third quarter. The rest were investors resubmitting amounts they couldn't get out earlier.

  • Cliffwater and Morgan Stanley. The $31 billion Cliffwater Corporate Lending Fund capped payouts for a second straight quarter, paying about a third of 16% in requests (after 17% in the second quarter). Morgan Stanley's North Haven Private Income Fund saw 11.4%, and nearly two-thirds of that came from investors already stuck in the queue.

  • The exceptions. Goldman Sachs' $18 billion GS Credit fund saw requests of only 2%, and KKR's international income fund about 2.5%. Their investor bases and portfolios look different, and so do their results.

The loans underneath are getting weaker.

Redemptions are a liquidity problem. Defaults are a value problem, and they are rising. Fitch's U.S. private credit default rate reached a record 6.3% for the 12 months through August 2026, up from 5.8% in January and above 6% every month since April. Over that period, Fitch counted 109 default events across 89 companies.

The stress is concentrated in smaller borrowers. Companies with less than $25 million in annual earnings (EBITDA) had a 12% default rate. Industrial and manufacturing companies were near 10%. More than half of recent defaults were not missed payments outright but borrowers deferring interest or paying it in more debt (known as payment-in-kind, or PIK), a sign of strain that shows up before losses do.

Not every measure is so grim. Law firm Proskauer, which tracks senior secured loans to larger borrowers, reported a 2.51% default rate in the second quarter, down from 2.73% in the first. In its first-quarter report, Proskauer also noted that software loans, the main source of investor anxiety, had stayed relatively stable. The gap depends on which loans are counted. The key point for fund investors is that the riskiest pockets are getting worse, even if the broad market is not breaking.

Who is struggling, and who isn’t

The trouble is concentrated. Smaller companies and three industries (healthcare providers, industrial manufacturers, and consumer businesses) carry most of the stress, while software borrowers are barely defaulting.


Software is the surprise. It was the main source of investor anxiety, and software-heavy funds such as Blue Owl’s OTIC saw the heaviest withdrawals, yet software defaults fell over the year. Proskauer also found software defaults stable. The redemption wave and the default wave are hitting different places.


What the trend lines say

The queue is mostly old requests. At Ares, Blue Owl and Morgan Stanley, most third-quarter requests were resubmissions from investors who couldn't fully exit earlier. Ares says brand-new requests were about 3% of assets, under the cap. It expects to largely clear its backlog by year-end if demand holds steady. Ares investors who first asked out in the first quarter will have received close to 80% of what they requested.

Fresh money has slowed sharply. Investment bank Robert A. Stanger counted $12.9 billion pulled from wealth-channel private credit funds in the first five months of 2026, and forecast BDC fundraising would fall roughly 40% this year. Fewer new dollars mean less cushion to pay departing investors.

Managers are diverging. Funds with heavy software exposure or concentrated investor bases, like Blue Owl's OTIC, were hit hardest. At the other end, Goldman's fund saw requests of just 2%. Some analysts expect elevated redemptions to last into early 2027.

What this means for investors

The 5% gates have worked as designed: no major fund has been forced into a fire sale. But 2026 has shown that "semi-liquid" means liquid only when most investors don't want out at the same time. If you own or are considering these funds, a few things are worth checking:

  1. Liquidity is conditional. Plan as if any money in a non-traded BDC could take a year or more to fully exit in a stressed market.

  2. Look at the queue, not just the headline. A high request number made up mostly of resubmissions is a backlog clearing. Rising new requests are a warning sign.

  3. Read the portfolio. Check non-accrual rates, the share of income paid in kind, software exposure, and average borrower size. Blue Owl's smaller fund shows how quickly a portfolio can weaken as loans are sold or repaid and problem loans make up more of what's left.

  4. Watch the distribution. Cuts like BCRED's are an early signal that income is under pressure.

  5. Separate the manager from the fund. A manager's falling stock price is not the same as losses in its funds, though the two can feed each other.

Private credit is not collapsing. But its first real test has shown that the asset class's biggest selling point, steady yield with periodic access to your money, comes with conditions that many investors didn't fully price in.

Book a Private Investment Strategy Call With Tom

Choose a Time Here